Translating Sanctions

I was catching news of the NCAA and self-imposed sanctions against Penn State football before hitting the road today. The list includes more than $70 million in fines and lost revenue, no bowl games, removal of a statue, and reduced scholarships for four years. There’s that “vacating” of wins for fourteen years. I think that’s an appropriate measure for the coach’s record. But it’s otherwise a silly gesture, even for a scandal like this. It strikes me as akin to a rewriting of history, erasing the public memory of events for a political purpose. Joe Paterno won more games as a coach than any other. He also allowed a sex predator to continue to molest and used the almighty power of college football to have his way. Maybe that’s embarassing for the NCAA to have Coach Paterno  at the top of the heap, but that’s the culture they’ve long-encouraged in big time college athletics. I hope they don’t think there aren’t other culture-of-football challenges ahead.

If the Catholic Church ever imposed sanctions on a diocese, let’s say Philadelphia, I was wondering today what that would look like.

Removal of the JoePa statue would sort of be like removing the burial remains from the cathedral crypt and putting them in an unmarked grave.

No bowl games for four years and an extra year of probation on top of that is like a generation in college sports. For a diocese, a generation would be like the active ministry life of a priest. No red hat and no metropolitan status for thirty to forty years.

Scholarships and fines … well, I don’t think you can take seminarians, priests, and money away from a diocese. Penn State will have a hard enough time paying fines without dipping into academics or women’s sports. Losing a bishop’s burial spot and a red hat? Man, that would hurt big time and there’s no money involved with that whatsoever. I guess the courts are already mandating abuse settlements, and dioceses are doing what PSU won’t be allowed to do: take money from innocent people.

Penn State football avoided the “death penalty.” Geez, what would that look like for Philadelphia? The actual archdiocese would be chopped up and reapportioned to Allentown, Harrisburg, and maybe even Camden, Trenton, and Wilmington. I think that’s under consideration in Ireland, though, a radical reduction in the number of bishops and dioceses.

There are still people who say that Penn State got off easy in all this. And many respected sports commentators are saying these were a little too strong. I’d have to concede that the NCAA and Penn State itself were far more serious about the eradication of the culture of silence around protecting sex predators. The Church would have to do a lot of distasteful things before it approached the impact of these penalties.


About catholicsensibility

Todd lives in the Pacific Northwest, serving a Catholic parish as a lay minister.
This entry was posted in Ministry, Sports. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Translating Sanctions

  1. David D. says:

    “Penn State will have a hard enough time paying fines without dipping into academics or women’s sports”

    After all, female students must undoubtedly be victims of the scandal above and beyond their male counterparts. I doubt what you suggest would pass muster under title IX.

    “I guess the courts are already mandating abuse settlements, and dioceses are doing what PSU won’t be allowed to do: take money from innocent

    What are you talking about? What courts are mandating settlements?

  2. Todd says:

    Where dioceses have lost civil suits, they have cut back ministries, closed parishes, and the like. Most would acknowledge that there is no direct connection, along the lines of “We were sued for $50M and lost. Now we’ll have to shut down the youth ministry office.” But those settlements affect the overall financial health and budgeting priorities. They have to.

    I see the governor or Pennsylvania insists PSU not pay the fines with state money. They will have to use football revenue. The NCAA insists that other sports not be sacrificed. But how will PSU balance Title IX? Twenty fewer football scholarships might mean twenty fewer scholarships for women athletes. Will the NCAA police that?

    I’m saying I’m a doubter thay these agreements can be kept separate. Football is part of the social and economic culture of a university. These penalties will impact the innocent just like sex abuse settlements have harmed the Catholic Church.

  3. Jimmy Mac says:

    The NCAA leaders serve at the behest of the participating schools. This is not true for Mother Church. Therein lies a major fault in your comparison.

    If the member schools are not happy with NCAA rulings, they can replace the leaders. But for MC?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s