Catholics In Exodus

I had avoided commenting on Archbishop Gomez’s speech from earlier this month. I find the talks and comments of bishops not my own to be far less interesting these days. But this chat got a lot of attention, even here in the secular media.

I think pastors are in a tough spot. It’s unhelpful and intemperate for a bishop to preach this:

But people are increasingly turning to these “woke” movements, rather than religion, for “an explanation for events and conditions in the world,” he said. “They offer a sense of meaning, a purpose for living, and the feeling of belonging to a community. … Like Christianity, these new movements tell their own ‘story of salvation.’”

“Now more than ever,” he said, “the church and every Catholic needs to know” the Christian story, “and proclaim it in all its beauty and truth.”

First, people interested in social justice don’t turn to organized religion because organizations self-identify with the privileged. Maybe not always the 1%–though that is part of it. The Church fails to tell the story of the Exodus, the prophetic voices of the Old Testament, and the healing miracles of the Lord. 

I detect a bit of envy in the sense of the archbishop’s words. 

I see the word “beauty” connected with the Church quite a bit these past several years. But there is a lot of ugliness in human behavior, even in humans associated with the Church.

Perhaps ignorance as well:

(T)hese strictly secular movements are causing new forms of social division, discrimination, intolerance and injustice.

Well, no. They are bringing these elements into the light.

Let’s take a page from Pope John Paul II’s apostolic exhortation on penance and reconciliation. Individuals are responsible for sin, not social movements. Individual people in any association–BLM, bishops, or whatever–make errors, have flaws, and commit sins. Bad behavior reflects poorly on an organization as a whole, and the more responsible a person is perceived, the more tarnish on the group. The cover-up of sexual abuse has gone as high as cardinals, which is pretty far up in the Church. Therefore, we operate at a handicap, and a significant one in circles close to us. 

Let’s get back to that tough spot. A nice parishioner couple left our parish some months ago. They were among the first people I met when I arrived. But they found the emphasis on racism and social justice difficult to swallow and they felt over-emphasized. It may be that the loss of members is inevitable. If it is, we might do better to do the right thing, rather than look to that secular value of the preservation of the institution.

Image credit: CNS/Bob Roller

About catholicsensibility

Todd lives in Minnesota, serving a Catholic parish as a lay minister.
This entry was posted in bishops, Church News and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Catholics In Exodus

  1. Devin Rice says:

    Woke is the new liberation theology. It can cover a wide range of concepts and ideas. Some are deeply connected to the heart of the Gospel. Other ideas and concepts also advocated under the banner of “being woke” are antithetical to that same Gospel.

    Do these secular movements point out grave injustices and advocate for victims of oppression? Yes.
    Do these same secular movements cause unjust discrimination/division and injustices? Yes.

    • I’m in agreement. But everything you’ve cited, and everything that the archbishop has cited, is true of the Church, institutionally, on all its levels–Rome, dioceses, parishes, and religious orders. We have no moral high ground on which to stand. We serve better associating with people when they align with our agenda, and sow seeds of reconciliation and unity. Archbishop Gomez actually works against the very principles he thinks the world needs more of. What he needs to do, if he is serious, is to befriend BLM and metoo people. Invite them to dinner. Attend their meetings and rallies. Failing that, giving up on the airport bishop schtick wouldn’t be bad, if this is the best he can do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s